Five Power Bats Who Can Fill Padres' Hole at Designated Hitter in 2026

The San Diego Padres will be in need of a full-time designated hitter in 2026. The lineup has struggled to hit for power for the past two seasons, and something is going to have to change if San Diego wants to truly be in contention in 2026. What better way to add some of that much-needed pop to the lineup than signing a veteran free-agent to focus all their time on hitting?

Here are five players who could fill that role in San Diego. 

1. Kyle Schwarber 

Schwarber is clearly the prize of the offseason when it comes to designated hitters, and for good reason. He's been one of the most consistent power hitters in the league for the past five years. Since 2021, he has a 136 OPS+, a .514 SLG, and 219 home runs (averaging 43 bombs per season)!

In 2025, he finished with red all over his Baseball Savant page, including a 100th percentile finish in Hard-Hit%. He also cracked the 99th percentile in batting run value, xSLG, and Barrel %, while ranking in the 98th percentile xwOBA, average exit velocity, and bat speed. He also had a great eye, finishing in the 97th percentile in walk rate. 

Obviously, there are two massive holes in his game that prevent him from being an MVP: he strikes out too much and does not play defense. But, for a lineup like San Diego, which already prominently features contact bats, Schwarber might actually be a breath of fresh air. He's a three-true-outcomes guy, which makes his at-bats as fun as they can be frustrating. After two years of employing contact king Luis Arraez, perhaps it's time San Diego tries going all-in on power. 

2. Marcell Ozuna 

Ozuna from the Braves had a down year in 2025, but there is still plenty of evidence to suggest he is capable of bouncing back. Remember, it was not that long ago that Ozuna was receiving MVP votes and was challenging Shohei Ohtani for the title of best DH in baseball. 

Ozuna's .400 slugging percentage was significantly lower than his xSLG of .437, and his analytics look solid. He finished in the 83rd percentile in xwOBA, and the 85th percentile in chase rate. Best of all, he was still drawing walks at an elite rate. Ozuna was in the 98th percentile in walk rate, a big reason why is OBP (.355) was over 120 points higher than his AVG (.232). 

Because of his age (35) and because he had a down year last year, Ozuna will probably be significantly cheaper than Schwarber. There's an inherent risk here, and the Padres don't want to hitch their wagon to another old, declining veteran. However, if Ozuna can get even halfway to where he was in 2024, he would be in contention once again as the second-best DH in the National League.

3. Andrew McCutchen 

This is where the DH class suddenly becomes very weak. There is a real argument that McCutchen, entering his age-39 season, is the third-best DH available. 

This is not a drag on McCutchen. He's been fine in his last three years in Pittsburgh, with a combined 104 OPS+ over 1,315 at-bats. The problem is he has no upside and a lot of risk. His age is a risk in and of itself, and he's also had a bad tendency to get hurt throughout his career. 

Like Schwarber and Ozuna, McCutchen is at least good for one thing: he walks a lot. His 12.2% walk rate placed him the 88th percentile in the league, and his chase rate also stayed very low, at just 20.7%. 

Still, it feels like whoever signs McCutchen (if it's not Pittsburgh) would be settling. McCutchen is the compensation prize, not the reward. 

4. Justin Turner

At this point, the veteran infielder is more of a DH than anything else. Once again, Turner would be a bounce-back candidate, and it's hard to predict how much he'll be able to bounce back at 41 years old. After 13 straight seasons with an OPS+ above 100, Turner's OPS+ fell all the way to 75 last year with the Cubs. He was worth -0.1 bWAR, his least valuable season since 2010. 

Signing Turner to be their DH would feel similar to the Jason Heyward signing last offseason, and we all know how that one turned out for San Diego. He'd bring a great presence to the clubhouse, but he's hardly a lock to upgrade the offense.

5. Starling Marte

The former Mets and Pirates star could be in the mix to play outfield as well, but at this point, he is more of a DH at 37 years old. He actually had a fine year in 2025, putting up an OPS+ of 111 and a bWAR of 1.0. However, that came after a very rough 2023-24, when he was worth -0.1 bWAR and had an 89 OPS+ in 180 games. 

Again, Marte should be considered a last resort for the Padres' need. He'd make sense as a tertiary addition to the lineup, not the primary one.