Jump to content
Padres Mission
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Padres Mission Contributor
Posted

The San Diego Padres entered the winter with certain needs. They need significant help in the rotation, they probably need an everyday left fielder, and it's looking increasingly like first base will be a source of need, too. A weak free agent class isn't set to satisfy all of their problems, which means that they'll have to look to the trade market to address their shortcomings on some level. 

That pathway toward improvement presents certain challenges, though. Namely, the fact that the Padres are operating with a lower-tier farm system from which to deal talent from.

In the majority of trades we see a team like the Padres make, prospects are a natural part of the deal. Those teams that are willing to trade starting-caliber talent are generally those that are also in some phase or other of a rebuild, meaning that younger, controllable players are going to offer the most appeal in any prospective swap. A.J. Preller's modus operandi of dealing away seemingly every noteworthy prospect in the organization (save Ethan Salas) over the last handful of seasons means that they're sitting at the bottom of the league's farm system rankings. 

That doesn't mean that an impactful deal becomes impossible, just very difficult. You could be looking at a situation where the Padres are forced to settle for a player with lower upside or are required to part with more volume in the way that they did when they acquired Ryan O'Hearn & Ramón Laureano at the 2025 trade deadline for six prospects. So, while they certainly could still strike a prospect-laden deal, there's a much more visible pathway toward the type of trade(s) they should seek this winter. 

There are a number of teams throughout the league that fancy themselves to be on the cusp of contention. Whether that's on the verge of the postseason itself or closer to a title contender is immaterial. It's the group of teams that are in that near-contention status that will search of major-league talent to fortify their roster. Part of that search could require them to give up major-league-caliber players of their own in order to boost areas of need.

Consider a team like the Pittsburgh Pirates. They have starting pitching and are in need of offense; the same could be said of the Seattle Mariners. Those teams that develop starting pitching quite well compared to that of their peers and are left with more than they actually need at the top level would make for a perfect trade partner with the Friars. Carmen Mlodzinski springs to mind out of Pittsburgh, while names like George Kirby or Emerson Hancock could be had out of Seattle.

Then you get into teams like the New York Yankees or Boston Red Sox—organizations that were contenders last year and are more likely to look at tweaks to their current roster. At certain spots, they possess enough depth that they could trade away players that are legitimate starters but not crucial to the long-term health of a competitive window. Think of someone like Will Warren for the former or Jarren Duran from the latter. 

Much of the Padres' own appeal stems from players who could benefit from a change of scenery or may find themselves blocked by the rise of others at their position. Jake Cronenworth, Freddy Fermin, or a couple of different relief pitchers fit this kind of profile. The framework of a deal involving those names could allow a contender or near-contender to upgrade an area of need while dealing from an area of strength. 

This is the type of team that the Padres will likely have to link this winter. Simply put: rebuilding squads want high-quality prospects, of which the Friars have very few of note. Instead, their game is going to be hunting those teams in a similar position to themselves.


View full article

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...