Bryce Johnson May Be Internal Answer To Padres' Bench Woes

Even at this late stage of the offseason, the San Diego Padres have a depth problem.

While the team's addition of Sung Mun Song helps to quell some concerns over the infield depth and lengthens the bench, the fact that there are at least two unsettled spots in the team's lineup (first base and designated hitter) lends itself to the idea that more help is needed on that front. Even with Song's versatility, we saw in 2025 how a dearth of stability with respect to the reserves can derail a team over the course of a 162-game season. 

The 2025 Padres relied primarily on Jose Iglesias as their guy off the bench. Beyond him, it was a rotating cast of characters that at various points included Jason Heyward, Connor Joe, Tyler Wade, Yuli Gurriel, Oscar González, Brandon Lockridge, Trenton Brooks, and Mason McCoy, some for much shorter spells than others. None of those players completed the year still in the organization, with the exception of Iglesias, whose value was purely in his versatility rather than any semblance of production off the bench (73 wRC+). It was a group unable to compensate for injuries to regulars such as Jackson Merrill and Xander Bogaerts as the season wore on, in addition to its inability to provide relief, when needed, in shorter stints for someone like Fernando Tatis Jr.

So, while Song provides legitimate offensive upside at multiple positions — and could end up allowing the team to rotate Jake Cronenworth in at first base while holding down the keystone himself over long stretches — the inevitability that injuries will arise feeds directly into the need for additional upside off the bench. 

Considering the lack of offensive talent at the upper levels of the minors and that most of the team's minor-league deals thus far have come on the mound, it seems certain that the Friars will explore further additions with the little bit of time that still remains this offseason. However, any discourse around the team's bench configuration at present may be overlooking a player they believe to be a valuable part of their roster: Bryce Johnson. 

A former San Francisco Giants draftee, Johnson was a former Padre at one point, albeit very briefly. He left as a free agent via a non-tender prior to 2025 but was quickly reacquired for catcher Brett Sullivan in April. Johnson wouldn't appear in a game for San Diego until June and only notched 55 games worth of playing time throughout last year. Despite the small sample for a player without much prospect pedigree, there was something of an indication that some value may lie in what he brings to the table.

In Johnson's most extended big league action (84 PA), he posted a slash that included a .342 average and a .383 on-base percentage. His wRC+ checked in at 135 and he added four steals. That all came in addition to his league-average defense across all three outfield spots. Up against the rest of the players that rotated through the Padre bench, it's pretty masterful production. 

The biggest issue with Johnson's output from 2025, though, is that it came on the strength of a .446 batting average on balls in play. His strikeout rate came in above 22 percent while his walk rate sat just under four. His contact rates and trends are relatively uninspiring.

And yet, as much as there is to indicate that such production is not repeatable, there are at least a couple of things working in Johnson's favor. 

For one, he hit line drives at a 33.3 percent clip. Line drive contact begets favorable BABIP rates, which was the case for him last year. His .298 xBA still would've been an upper-percentile figure had he enough plate appearances to qualify. Such contact came largely against breaking pitches (42.9 percent) and fastballs (35.3 percent). There appeared to be an adjustment in the approach at play that led to these results, as well. Johnson swung at 11 percent fewer off-speed pitches, which were often a source of struggle (his xBA, hard-hit rate, and line-drive rate have largely all been at their lowest against that pitch type), historically. Given that, there's at least some semblance of hope that he can replicate those numbers on some level, even if at not quite the same gaudy pace. 

Johnson isn't an especially flashy or tools-y bat off the bench. He also doesn't offer much of anything on the power side (.092 ISO). But if you can get a keen approach that emphasizes those pitches against which he succeeds, there's enough contact and on-base ability in there to allow him to become a valuable part of the bench rotation, especially when you factor in the ability to steal a base and provide steady glove work on the outfield grass. 

Of course, even another successful year from Bryce Johnson doesn't offset the need for more help in the depth department. The Padres will certainly need to add a bit of extra power off the bench. At the same time, we shouldn't discount Johnson's role in upgrading the unit as a regular reserve player with a much larger sample than the one he saw last year.