Is The Twins' Ryan Jeffers The Padres Cure At Catcher?

[Braden Ramsey]

By virtue of Manny Machado's 2,000th hit, July 7th, 2025, is a day that will go down in Padres' history. It will also hopefully represent the day that the straw broke the camel's back with regard to San Diego's current catching situation.

It's no secret that the tandem of Martin Maldonado and Elias Diaz has been... underwhelming (and that's putting it kindly). By fWAR, they form the second-worst catching group in Major League Baseball. Entering Tuesday's action, they are the third-worst MLB catching room in wRC+ and OPS. Their standing in the latter category has somehow fallen two spots in the five days since The Athletic's Ken Rosenthal reported the Padres were scouring the market for an "offensive upgrade" at the position.

Most teams with good offensive catchers aren't keen on trading them away, which leaves A.J. Preller two options: proceed as currently constructed (yuck) or pluck from an already depleted farm system to fill the void. If he goes the second route, Twins Daily's Cody Christie believes Minnesota catcher Ryan Jeffers could be balm for the Padres' catching woes.

Quote

"Catchers who can contribute meaningfully with the bat are rare commodities, especially those with team control beyond this season. That’s where Jeffers comes in." - Cody Christie, Twins Daily

Jeffers, 28, is having a solid offensive season (.237/.336/.377, 15 2B, 6 HR, 29 RBI, 26 R) with career-best walk rates (11.4%) and strikeout rates (18.5%). His wRC+ (103) is a handful of ticks below his 2024 number (106), but both are essentially league-average figures. He ranks 18th among MLB catchers (min. 100 PA) in the metric this year. Unsurprisingly, Diaz (wRC+ of 71) and Maldonado (49) are much worse. 

Jeffers is not as good defensively as Diaz, and his defensive reputation doesn't match Maldonado's. However, in 2025, Jeffers has been better than Maldonado behind the plate. He is inferior as a framer, but vastly superior as a blocker -- where Maldonado is the league's fourth-worst catcher -- and thrower, where Maldonado is at the bottom of the barrel.

	Blocks Above Average	CS Above Average	Framing Runs	Fielding Run Value (Percentile)
Elias Diaz	2	2	-2	40
Ryan Jeffers	0	0	-3	20
Martin Maldonado	-7	-6	-1	3

(Data courtesy of Baseball Savant.)

Acquiring Jeffers to replace Maldonado for just the remainder of the 2025 campaign would be immensely helpful, but he'd also provide major dividends beyond this season. Maldonado is playing on a one-year deal, while Diaz has a $7 million mutual option for 2026. Jeffers is slated to hit free agency following the 2026 season, but shapes up as a much better financial investment than Diaz as a one-year bridge or longer-term complement to Ethan Salas.

On paper, Jeffers makes a ton of sense for San Diego. But without Jeffers, the Twins would find themselves in a similar predicament to the Padres at the major league level. And they don't have a high-end catching prospect, like Salas, developing in the wings. For these reasons, it'd take a hefty offer to snatch Jeffers from Minnesota, in Christie's opinion.

Quote

"[The Padres would] need to pay a premium: a combination of near-ready pitching and long-term upside... arms like Braden Nett or Henry Baez [are possibilities], and they could dangle someone like Tirso Ornelas as a big-league-ready outfielder. But the Twins aren’t likely to entertain the idea unless blown away by a multi-player package deal." - Cody Christie, Twins Daily

Nett, Baez and Ornelas, who made his MLB debut on Apr. 19, are San Diego's best prospects that, per MLB.com's rankings, should be ready to debut in 2025 or 2026. Ornelas is the lone position player among the Padres' top 30 prospects expected to be ready before 2027, so his potential loss could sting.

However, it's clear this team can't make a deep playoff run (and may not be able to make the postseason at all) without catching reinforcements. If that's the goal, parting with prospect capital is a necessity, whether it be for Jeffers or an alternative. 

Would you support the Padres swapping the likes of Braden Nett, Henry Baez and/or Tirso Ornelas -- or others -- for Ryan Jeffers? Let us know in the comments. And, as always, stay locked in on all Padres news and rumors right here at Padres Mission.

View full article